S1D LabsInvestigation · 19 Nov 2026

S1D Labs investigation · 19 November 2026 · Version 3

The Patiala bypass bridge: who built it, who maintained it, who signed

A 60 m steel truss bridge on NH-07 collapsed over the Bhakra Main Line canal on 19 November 2026. NHAI says the Border Roads Organisation built it. NHAI's own records show who owned, inspected and paid for its upkeep after that.

Summary

  1. The Border Roads Organisation (BRO) built the bridge, about 2011, under Punjab PWD supervision. NHAI confirms this.
  2. NHAI has owned and maintained the bridge since 2018. NHAI says so in its own post on the day of the collapse.
  3. NHAI's maintenance contract for this stretch requires a quarterly inspection of every bridge for structural damage, and a detailed condition inspection before each monsoon.
  4. On the day, the maintenance contract was with M/s Gaurav Singh. NHAI awarded it at 43.77% below its own estimate. Every maintenance award on this stretch since 2022 was 36% to 44% below estimate.
  5. The 2024 contract's price list had no item to repair a steel truss. The only bridge item was expansion joints: 0.54% of the estimate.
  6. In September 2025 an NHAI engineer said the joints of this canal bridge needed "urgent rectification to ensure the structure's safety".
  7. We do not know what NHAI's bridge inspections found. Our questions to NHAI are in Section 10.

Status labels: Verified = we read the primary document. Reported = news report only. Unchecked = one source, or a firm's own claim. Probable = several sources agree, no single proof.

1. What happened

At about 06:00 on 19 November 2026, the left-hand (LHS) span of a steel truss bridge fell. The bridge carries the Patiala bypass of NH-64 (new NH-07) over the Bhakra Main Line canal, near Pasiana village. Two trucks loaded with sand were on the span. One truck caught fire. Nobody died. At least one driver was hurt.

NHAI's Regional Office in Chandigarh posted a traffic advisory the same morning (Exhibit 1).

Exhibit 1: NHAI's traffic advisory. NHAI states the length (60 m), the type (steel truss), the side (LHS), the 2018 handover and the current maintenance contract.
Exhibit 1. NHAI's traffic advisory. NHAI states the length (60 m), the type (steel truss), the side (LHS), the 2018 handover and the current maintenance contract.Source: @NHAIRO_CHD on X, 19 Nov 2026 (screenshot). Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.

2. What NHAI said, and what it left out

At 12:40 NHAI posted a clarification (Exhibit 2). It says that BRO built the bridge under Punjab PWD supervision. It asks people not to spread "unverified or factually incorrect information".

Exhibit 2: NHAI's clarification. In the same post NHAI confirms that the section was handed over to NHAI in 2018 and is under NHAI's maintenance contract.
Exhibit 2. NHAI's clarification. In the same post NHAI confirms that the section was handed over to NHAI in 2018 and is under NHAI's maintenance contract.Source: @NHAIRO_CHD on X, 12:40, 19 Nov 2026 (screenshot). Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.

The statement about the builder is correct. It does not say who looked after the bridge. Since 2018, inspection and repair of this bridge is NHAI's job, under NHAI's own contracts. Sections 4 to 7 show those contracts.

3. Who built the bridge

The bypass was a Defence project. In May 2005 the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH) accepted a Defence Ministry proposal. BRO was to build a Patiala bypass on NH-64 for Army traffic to the border. The estimate was Rs 37 crore. BRO's Project Chetak started work in 2007. The cost went up to Rs 110 crore. The contractor left midway. BRO missed six deadlines. The road opened in June 2015, in poor condition.

The steel truss over the canal was made by Traders & Engineers Pvt Ltd, Kolkata. The company's portfolio describes it as a "60 meters long (C/C of Abutment Bearings) Single Span Major PMT Bridge with Footpaths with Steel Truss Super Structure (Through Type) and Sub Structure on Pile Foundations over Bhakra Main Canal at Km 17.510 on road Patiala Southern Bye-Pass under Project Chetak". The company gives the date as 2011.

In 2015 the Punjab PWD took over the road and widened it to four lanes. NHAI's own project database records this work as an EPC contract (UPC N/05012/02002/PB, km 50.000 to 69.870). It was awarded on 11 March 2015 for Rs 305 crore and completed on 28 October 2016. The section went to NHAI in 2018.

Why some reports say "built in 2016". The four-laning was completed in October 2016. The truss that fell is older: it is part of BRO's original two-lane road (about 2011).
Which agency was responsible for the bridge, 2005 to 2026200520072009201120132015201720192021202320252027Border Roads OrganisationBRO builds the 2-lane bypass and the 60 m truss (2007–2015)Punjab PWD (B&R)PWD executes the four-laning (EPC, awarded 11 Mar 2015, completed 28 Oct 2016)NHAINHAI owns and maintains the section (2018 – collapse)2005: Centre accepts Defence proposal2005: Centre accepts Defence proposal~2011: 60 m truss built~2011: 60 m truss builtSep 2025: urgent joint repairSep 2025: urgent joint repair19 Nov 2026: collapse19 Nov 2026: collapse
Figure 1. Which agency was responsible for the road. BRO built it, Punjab PWD four-laned it, NHAI has owned and maintained it since 2018. Tap or hover a band for details.Data: The Tribune (2005, 2013, 2014, 2017); NHAI posts of 19 Nov 2026; NHAI Project Information (UPC N/05012/02002/PB); Traders & Engineers Pvt Ltd portfolio.

4. Who maintained it, and who signed

NHAI does not maintain highways with its own staff. It gives short maintenance contracts to private contractors, and it appoints a supervision consultant to check their work. We found every such contract for this stretch in NHAI's award records on etenders.gov.in, with the letter of acceptance (LoA) for each one.

Tender IDWorkContractorPriceBelow NHAI estimateLetter dateLoA signed by (NHAI)
2021_NHAI_81978_1Maintenance, km 50.000–69.280, 240 daysVMAKS Construction Pvt Ltd, Faridabad₹99,99,89033.77%10 Sep 2021Priyanka Meena, GM (Tech)
2022_NHAI_126864_1Maintenance, km 50.000–110.720, 24 monthsM/s A S Patel, Modasa, Gujarat₹5,54,09,78742.09% (of ₹9,56,82,588)18 Nov 2022Aashim Bansal, DGM (Tech)
2022_NHAI_118523_1Supervision consultant, km 0–110.720, 3 yearsMSV International Inc with Mahamarg Infra Consultant Pvt Ltd₹3,80,10,000 + GST–24 Nov 2022Aashim Bansal, DGM (Tech)
2024_NHAI_200504_1Maintenance, km 50.000–110.720, 12 months (2nd call)M/s Kamdhenu Construction, Prayagraj₹2,64,12,13935.99% (of ₹4,12,62,519)9 Sep 2024Aashish Garg, DGM (Tech)
2025_NHAI_250918_1Maintenance, km 50.000–123.900, 1 year (in force on 19 Nov 2026)M/s Gaurav Singh, Assandh, Haryana₹9,89,07,32943.77% (of ₹17,58,97,793)15 Dec 2025Vipon Kumar, DGM (Tech)
2025_NHAI_246021_1Supervision consultant, km 0–110.720, 3 yearsLion Engineering Consultants Pvt Ltd with Hadimba Consultants₹4,91,43,500 + GST–25 Mar 2026Vipon Kumar, DGM (Tech)

Every letter says: "This issue with the approval of RO Chandigarh". The Regional Officer of NHAI Chandigarh approved each award.

Exhibit 3: The letter of acceptance for the contract that was in force on the day of the collapse: ₹9,89,07,329, a discount of 43.77% on NHAI's estimate of ₹17,58,97,793, issued with the approval of RO Chandigarh. Because the bid was very low, NHAI also asked for an additional performance security of ₹4,18,10,905.
Exhibit 3. The letter of acceptance for the contract that was in force on the day of the collapse: ₹9,89,07,329, a discount of 43.77% on NHAI's estimate of ₹17,58,97,793, issued with the approval of RO Chandigarh. Because the bid was very low, NHAI also asked for an additional performance security of ₹4,18,10,905.Source: NHAI letter of acceptance, tender 2025_NHAI_250918_1, etenders.gov.in award record. Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.
Exhibit 4: Four firms bid for the current maintenance contract. NHAI found all four technically qualified.
Exhibit 4. Four firms bid for the current maintenance contract. NHAI found all four technically qualified.Source: NHAI office order on the technical bids, tender 2025_NHAI_250918_1. Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.
Exhibit 5: The 2024 maintenance contract: ₹2,64,12,139, a discount of 35.99% on the estimate of ₹4,12,62,519.
Exhibit 5. The 2024 maintenance contract: ₹2,64,12,139, a discount of 35.99% on the estimate of ₹4,12,62,519.Source: NHAI letter of acceptance, tender 2024_NHAI_200504_1. Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.
Exhibit 6: The 2022 maintenance contract: ₹5,54,09,787, a discount of 42.09% on the estimate of ₹9,56,82,588.
Exhibit 6. The 2022 maintenance contract: ₹5,54,09,787, a discount of 42.09% on the estimate of ₹9,56,82,588.Source: NHAI letter of acceptance, tender 2022_NHAI_126864_1. Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.
NHAI estimate and awarded price for each contract, in Rs crore₹0 cr₹3 cr₹6 cr₹9 cr₹12 cr₹15 cr₹18 crMaintenance 2022–24A S PatelNHAI estimate: ₹9.57 croreAwarded: ₹5.54 crore (42.09% below estimate)₹9.57 cr₹5.54 cr · 42.1% belowMaintenance 2024–25Kamdhenu ConstructionNHAI estimate: ₹4.13 croreAwarded: ₹2.64 crore (35.99% below estimate)₹4.13 cr₹2.64 cr · 36.0% belowMaintenance 2025–26Gaurav SinghNHAI estimate: ₹17.59 croreAwarded: ₹9.89 crore (43.77% below estimate)₹17.59 cr₹9.89 cr · 43.8% belowKm 60.682 bridge rebuildN.B. ConstructionNHAI estimate: ₹1.74 croreAwarded: ₹1.46 crore (16.25% below estimate)₹1.74 cr₹1.46 cr · 16.2% below
Figure 2. NHAI's own estimate (blue) and the price NHAI accepted (orange) for each contract on this stretch. Tap or hover a bar for the exact amount.Data: NHAI letters of acceptance (Exhibits 3, 5 and 6) and NHAI award list FY 2022-23, row 196.

A low price is legal. NHAI awards the work to the lowest valid bid. But a contract at 44% below the estimate pays for much less work than NHAI planned. NHAI must then make sure that the inspections are still done.

Were there gaps in cover?

Figure 3 shows each contract from its letter date. The real start dates are not public, so the gaps are approximate.

Maintenance and supervision contracts on the bridge stretch, counted from the letter date20212022202320242025202620272028MaintenanceVMAKS: letter 10 Sep 2021, 240 days (to about May 2022)VMAKSA S Patel: letter 18 Nov 2022, 730 days (to about Nov 2024)A S PatelKamdhenu: letter 09 Sep 2024, 365 days (to about Sep 2025)KamdhenuGaurav Singh: letter 15 Dec 2025, 365 days (to about Dec 2026)Gaurav SinghNo contract found in the records: about May 2022 to Nov 2022No contract found in the records: about Sep 2025 to Dec 2025SupervisionMSV International: letter 24 Nov 2022, 1095 days (to about Nov 2025)MSV InternationalLion Engineering: letter 25 Mar 2026, 1095 days (to about Mar 2029)Lion EngineeringNo contract found in the records: about Nov 2025 to Mar 2026Collapse, 19 Nov 2026No contract found in NHAI records (an extension is possible)
Figure 3. Maintenance (aqua) and supervision (blue) contracts on the stretch, counted from the letter date. Hatched: periods with no contract in NHAI's published records. NHAI may have extended a contract; we ask NHAI to confirm.Data: NHAI letters of acceptance and etenders.gov.in award records.
Two dates on one letter. The current maintenance letter is dated 15/12/2025 at the top. The officer signed it by hand on the same date. The digital signature on the copy uploaded to etenders.gov.in is dated 9 May 2026. NHAI's list of works "balance for award" of 1 March 2026 still showed this contract as not awarded. We use the letter date. We ask NHAI to confirm the start date.
Exhibit 7: Top of the current letter: dated 15/12/2025.
Exhibit 7. Top of the current letter: dated 15/12/2025.Source: NHAI letter of acceptance, tender 2025_NHAI_250918_1. Crop only; no highlight.
Exhibit 8: Bottom of the same letter: hand signature dated 15/12/25, digital signature dated 2026.05.09.
Exhibit 8. Bottom of the same letter: hand signature dated 15/12/25, digital signature dated 2026.05.09.Source: NHAI letter of acceptance, tender 2025_NHAI_250918_1. Crop only; no highlight.
Exhibit 9: NHAI's own list, status as on 1 March 2026, still shows the one-year maintenance contract for km 50–123.9 as
Exhibit 9. NHAI's own list, status as on 1 March 2026, still shows the one-year maintenance contract for km 50–123.9 as "balance for award".Source: NHAI, Balance for Award, 01-March-2026, row 352. Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.

5. What the contract required

The maintenance contract tells the contractor what to inspect and how often. These are the clauses from the 2024 contract for this stretch (km 50.000 to 110.720).

Exhibit 10: Quarterly inspections must include
Exhibit 10. Quarterly inspections must include "Bridges – structural elements for damage".Source: NHAI tender document, maintenance of km 50.000–110.720, July 2024 (RFP_621.pdf, page 104). Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.
Exhibit 11: Before each monsoon, the contractor must make a
Exhibit 11. Before each monsoon, the contractor must make a "detailed condition inspection of all bridges", followed by repairs as required.Source: Same document, page 105. Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.

The contract also says: "Repairs arising out of the inspections shall be carried out by the Contractor [...] after a joint assessment with the Engineer and approval of NHAI." So the inspection results must reach NHAI. The supervision consultant also has a named Bridge/Structural Engineer in each contract. In April 2025 NHAI also told its project directors to rate every bridge twice a year (policy circular 6.41/2025, as reported).

The contract requires these inspections. We ask NHAI to publish the reports.

6. What the contract paid for

A maintenance contract pays item by item, from a price list called the bill of quantities (BOQ). We read the BOQ of the 2024 contract (estimate ₹4,12,62,519) line by line. Figure 4 groups the 38 items.

What the 2024 maintenance contract priced, by type of workRoad surface, drains, cleaning₹177.43 lakh (43.00% of ₹4,12,62,519)₹177.4 lakh · 43.0%Signs, marking, barriers, lights₹154.54 lakh (37.45% of ₹4,12,62,519)₹154.5 lakh · 37.5%Median, plants, painting₹59.31 lakh (14.37% of ₹4,12,62,519)₹59.3 lakh · 14.4%Incident management₹18.01 lakh (4.37% of ₹4,12,62,519)₹18.0 lakh · 4.4%Bridge joints (item A10)₹2.23 lakh (0.54% of ₹4,12,62,519)₹2.2 lakh · 0.5%
Figure 4. What the 2024 maintenance contract priced. The only item that names a bridge part is the replacement of damaged expansion joints (orange). There is no item for steel repair, bearings, bolts, painting of a truss, or a structural survey.Data: NHAI BOQ for tender 2024_NHAI_200504_1 (BOQ_247.xls), amounts as estimated by NHAI.
ItemDescription (NHAI's words, shortened)QuantityAmount (₹)
A3Cleaning of carriageways, footpaths, verges, expansion joints, drainage spouts of bridge (twice a year)25,100 m12,55,000
A10Providing and installation of damaged strip seal expansion joint [...] for bridge50 m2,23,214
B3Painting with synthetic enamel paint on old wood work or metallic or plastered or concrete surface42,720 sqm24,41,021
A116 to 8 mm microsurfacing (road surface)40,000 sqm57,60,000
C8Road marking with hot applied thermoplastic8,640 sqm47,57,184

The table shows the bridge-related items next to the two largest road items. NHAI could repair the truss under a separate contract. We searched NHAI tenders from 2017 to November 2026 on etenders.gov.in. We found no NHAI Chandigarh tender for a bridge inspection, structural audit, condition survey or load test on this road.

7. Warnings before the collapse

September 2025: "urgent rectification"

On 20 September 2025 The Tribune reported that NHAI closed one side of the bridge over the canal at the 68-km mark for two to three weeks.

"The expansion joints [...] have been found damaged and require urgent rectification to ensure the structure's safety." NHAI Superintending Engineer Abhishek Chauhan, as reported by The Tribune, 20 September 2025.

The closed side was Sangrur to Chandigarh. On NHAI's chainage that is normally the right-hand carriageway. The span that fell is the left-hand one. We ask NHAI which side it repaired and what else the inspection found.

2022: another BRO steel truss on the same bypass needed a new superstructure

The bypass has a second, smaller steel truss: a 41.5 m "minor bridge" over a stream at km 60.682 (62+645 in some NHAI documents). In 2022 NHAI decided to demolish and rebuild its deck slab and superstructure. NHAI cancelled the first tender "due to administrative reasons", widened the scope, and awarded the work to M/s N.B. Construction Company, Kaithal, for ₹1,45,93,019 (letter of 17 January 2023).

Exhibit 12: NHAI's description of the km 60.682 bridge: composite steel truss, one span of 41.50 m, LHS.
Exhibit 12. NHAI's description of the km 60.682 bridge: composite steel truss, one span of 41.50 m, LHS.Source: NHAI tender 47420, Technical Schedules (October 2022), page 4. Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.
Exhibit 13: The same tender: the old superstructure is to be dismantled and a new girder bridge built. This bridge crosses a stream (
Exhibit 13. The same tender: the old superstructure is to be dismantled and a new girder bridge built. This bridge crosses a stream ("rivers/streams/nallas"), not the Bhakra canal, so it is a different bridge from the one that fell.Source: NHAI tender 47420, Technical Schedules, page 19. Yellow on the chainage and "Dismantling existing bridge" added by S1D Labs. The yellow on "Minor Bridges (OVER RIVERS/ STREAMS/ NALLAS)" and "Only LHS side minor Bridge shall be reconstructed" is in NHAI's original.
Exhibit 14: NHAI's award list: the km 60.682 work went to N.B. Construction Company for ₹1.46 crore, letter of 17 January 2023.
Exhibit 14. NHAI's award list: the km 60.682 work went to N.B. Construction Company for ₹1.46 crore, letter of 17 January 2023.Source: NHAI, projects awarded in FY 2022-23, row 196. Yellow highlight added by S1D Labs. Nothing else is changed.
Schematic of the Patiala bypass, NHAI chainage km 50 to 69.28 (not to scale across)km 50km 55km 60km 65km 69.28Rajpura / Patiala sideSangrur sideKm 60.682: 41.5 m steel truss over a stream. NHAI rebuilt its superstructure (letter 17 Jan 2023)Km 60.682: 41.5 m steel truss over a streamNHAI rebuilt its superstructure (letter 17 Jan 2023)Km ≈67.5: 60 m steel truss over the Bhakra canal. LHS span collapsed 19 Nov 2026 (Passiana)Km ≈67.5: 60 m steel truss over the Bhakra canalLHS span collapsed 19 Nov 2026 (Passiana)
Figure 5. The two BRO steel trusses on the Patiala bypass. Positions are NHAI chainages. The position of the collapsed bridge comes from NHAI's accident map ("Patiala bypass near Passiana", "Bridge Location", km 67.5–68.0) and the steel contractor's km 17.510 on the bypass (17.510 + 50 = 67.51).Data: NHAI tender 47420; NHAI road-accident map layer (datalakew.nhai.gov.in); Traders & Engineers Pvt Ltd portfolio.

In 2022 NHAI found that one BRO-era truss on this road needed a new superstructure. We found no record that NHAI checked the larger truss over the canal in the same way.

8. Claims we checked

ClaimVerdictWhy
"NHAI built the bridge in 2016" (several news sites)FalseBRO built the truss about 2011. The four-laning by Punjab PWD finished in October 2016 (Section 3).
NHAI: BRO built it under PWD supervisionIncompleteCorrect about the builder. It leaves out that NHAI has owned and maintained the bridge since 2018 (Sections 4–6).
"The bridge was 60 m long"TrueNHAI's advisory; the steel contractor's record (60 m between bearings).
"It was a Bailey bridge"FalseA Bailey bridge is a temporary panel bridge. This was a permanent through-type truss on pile foundations.
"The trucks fell into the canal"FalseThe trucks stayed in the fallen span.
"No casualties" / "several injured"Both partly trueNobody died. At least one driver was hurt.
"Overloaded sand trucks caused it"Not provenThe Deputy Commissioner, citing NHAI's first report, said a truck broke down mid-span and two more stopped behind it. No truck weights and no load limit for the bridge are public.
"Built in 2000"Probably falseBRO started the bypass in 2007.
"Handed to NHAI in 2021"ConflictsNHAI says 2018. NHAI's maintenance tenders for this section start in December 2020.
"A magisterial inquiry was ordered"Partly reportedFour outlets report an inquiry by the district administration. Only Aaj Tak says "magisterial". We have not seen an order.
Old pictures of a "Bhakra canal bridge collapse"CheckA village bridge at Shutrana collapsed on 17 Oct 2025. It is a different event.

9. What we do not know

  1. NHAI's inspection reports and condition rating for this bridge since 2018, and who signed them.
  2. Who maintained the stretch from about September to December 2025, and who supervised it from about November 2025 to March 2026.
  3. The 2018 handover record: the joint inspection and the list of defects.
  4. What else the September 2025 inspection found, and which side NHAI repaired.
  5. The design load of the bridge, any posted load limit, and the weights of the trucks.
  6. The content of NHAI's report to the Deputy Commissioner on 19 November.

MoRTH's bridge database (IBMS) keeps a condition rating for national highway bridges. Its data needs a login. We did not try to get past the login.

10. Right of reply

We are sending the questions in Section 9 to NHAI Regional Office Chandigarh. We are asking M/s Gaurav Singh, Lion Engineering Consultants, MSV International, M/s Kamdhenu Construction and M/s A S Patel two questions. Which bridge inspections did they do on this stretch? What did they report to NHAI? We are asking BRO, Punjab PWD and Traders & Engineers Pvt Ltd to confirm the construction details. We will publish every answer here, in full or in fair summary, with the date.

11. Method

We used only public records. We did not use any login, bot check bypass or private source.

Data

Steps

  1. We placed the bridge. We matched NHAI's chainages, the accident map point near Passiana, the steel contractor's km 17.510 and the 2025 news report.
  2. We listed every NHAI contract on the stretch and opened each award letter. We read the price, the discount, the dates and the signature.
  3. We read the maintenance contract's scope and its price list item by item.
  4. We checked each public claim against a primary document. Where we had only a news report, we say "reported".
  5. For the exhibits, we searched each document for the exact words and highlighted them in yellow. For scanned letters we used optical character recognition to find the words. We changed nothing else on any page.

Checks

FactChecked againstStatus
NHAI owns and maintains the section since 2018NHAI posts, 19 Nov 2026Verified
BRO built the truss; 60 m, through typeNHAI post; steel contractor's portfolioVerified Unchecked (year 2011)
Four-laning: EPC, ₹305 cr, 11 Mar 2015 – 28 Oct 2016NHAI Project Information, UPC N/05012/02002/PBVerified
Contract prices, discounts, letter dates, signatoriesLetters of acceptance on etenders.gov.inVerified
Quarterly and pre-monsoon bridge inspections requiredNHAI RFP for km 50–110.72 (2024), pages 104–105Verified
No truss repair item; joints = 0.54% of estimateNHAI BOQ_247.xls (2024)Verified
Sep 2025 "urgent rectification" quoteThe Tribune, 20 Sep 2025Reported
Km 60.682 bridge is a different bridgeNHAI tender 47420 schedules (stream crossing, 41.5 m)Verified
Collapsed bridge at km 67.5–68NHAI accident map; contractor's km 17.510; Tribune 2025Probable
No bridge inspection or audit tender on this roadOur copy of etenders.gov.in, NHAI tenders 2017 – Nov 2026Verified (in our copy)

Limits

Corrections

Version 1 (19 Nov, 13:56) used the upload dates of the award letters, not the letter dates. It said that the current contract was awarded six months late. That was wrong. Version 2 corrected the dates. Version 3 adds the exhibits, the charts and the four-laning record.

Sources

NHAI

Construction history

The collapse and earlier repairs

Rules